There is some discussion again about what should be on topic for Planet Debian, whether it should be used for Debian-related announcements and what the archival policy should be. I believe that this discussion is rooted in two circulating views of what Planet Debian should be:
- A forum for DD's to post Debian-related thoughts and ideas, to be used for those cases where they think a mailing list post may be less appropriate;
- A way to collect stories about what DD's do and think in any context, the human interest angle: get to know your Debian peers more than just in technical matters.
Although I always regarded Planet Debian to be the latter and I appreciate reading posts telling me about someone's job or other interests, either one isn't an invalid approach per se. They do however prompt different choices about listing policy (Debian-only feeds vs. everything goes), how much effort it is to keep up with them and perhaps archival.
The best way to match the expectations of those two groups would be to create two "planets", one for each group. Create an aggregator where any DD can add any of their feeds, and another one with a strict listing policy: only feeds that carry posts actually related to Debian development matters (probably a subset of the first). Then only the question remains which one will get to carry the Planet Debian name...